Monday, March 19, 2012

Some second thoughts regarding the Violence Against Women Act


 by Thaddeus Blanchette 

(Tip ó the hat to Dr. Gregory Mitchell for the graphic, although the opinions expressed here are strictly my own)


Recently, my social media pages have been filling up with friends and relatives urging me to support the Violence Against Women Act currently in front of Congress. VAWA is generally something I would support reflexively. However, having learned that the U.S. has an unsavory tendency to hide very retrograde policy wolves in apparently progressive sheeps' clothing, I decided to actually look at how VAWA would affect the lives of the women I am currently most concerned with: Brazilian immigrants to the U.S.

After going through VAWA, I've come to the conclusion that while it may be a sincere attempt to deal with many issues raised by domestic violence, it stinks when it comes to immigration. Right now, VAWA's International Marriage Broker (IMB) riders set unreasonable restrictions on foreign women's freedoms in the name of "protecting" these "potential victims". Many of my friends tout the fact that the new version of VAWA will cover LGBT folks as a great reason for supporting it. Unfortunately, I don't see how extending these "protections" to the LGBT crowd make the Act any better.

Look at this...

"[VAWA] limits sharing information about the foreign fiancée or spouse until IMBs search the National Sex Offender Public Registry or State sex offender public registry and search for criminal history of the U.S. client and receive a signed, written consent from the foreign fiancée or spouse to release her information to the U.S. client."

...and...

"[VAWA] mandates U.S. citizens filing for K visas to disclose criminal convictions, including domestic violence, multiple convictions for substance or alcohol abuse and other violent crimes; the information
will be disclosed to the foreign fiancée or spouse."


Sounds like reasonable stuff, right? Until you start asking how all this is going to be operationalized in a country like Brazil.

What's first of all apparent to someone who's studied international marriage and dating (like myself) is how radically out of touch this law is with the ways IMBs and dating sites work. If it worked as intended, it would effectively shut down a huge amount of international contact between American men and foreign women, unless the latter were effectively middle class (and probably white).
 

However, VAWA's IMB rider just silly. Any idiot with a website and a proxy can effectively organize an international "boy meets girl" site and there isn't a damned thing the government can do about it. So REAL trafficking - the sort which recruits people for sexual slavery or very dodgy servile marriages - isn't going to be impacted one single bit by VAWA's IMB rider.

Who's going to be hit? John Doe and Maria da Silva, who're going to have to jump through yet another series of federally mandated legal hoops (which may or may not be practicable at a local level in a place like Brazil) if they fall in love and want to get married.

Here's something which most of you folks haven't done but I have: married a foreigner. You should think about VAWA in this context. What does it actually take to marry a foreigner and bring them to the U.S. and how will VAWA likely impact that?

In Brazil, ALL paperwork regarding marriage and fianceé visas needs to pass through the U.S. consulate in Rio de Janeiro, which is great if you met someone on the RdJ/SP axis. But go take a look at Brazil on a globe. Notice how it's larger than the continental U.S.? You are shit out of luck, my friend, if you happen to fall in love with someone in, say, Goias. Every bureaucratic step in your visa processing is going to require a 600 USD round trip air ticket between Goias and Rio and VAWA just added at least two further steps to the visa process.

Furthermore, all this VAWA reporting stuff is going to have to be produced in Portuguese for your prospective spouse and I highly doubt the U.S. Consulate will be footing the translation bill. Seeing as how it will need to have to be an "official" translation, produced by a certified court translator, in order to have any legal relevance at all, that's probably going to add a couple of thousand bucks to the visa process as well.

Either that, or we're just pissing in the wind here, presuming that a vice-consul, who deals with 50 visa applications a day, is going to competently and carefully translate some guy's VAWA report from English to Portuguese on the fly. And remember: you get a black mark on your VAWA report if you've ever even been busted for smoking a joint or violating an open beverage law, though it's absolutely unclear what link any of these two "crimes" has to violence against women.

And is all this visa rigamarole going to materially aid a significant number of foreign women in the struggle against abusive husbands? Probably not. It puts a heavy burden on the new couple, one which would be absolutely unbearable if it were directed against AMERICAN women.
One only needs to think of the stink something like this would cause were the government to suggest that American women's private coorespondence with men via singles sites be vetted by the FBI before being allowed to go through.


Government tutelage of women, anyone?

I mean think about it: how would you feel if you had to fly from wherever you live to Philadelphia three, four, or five times, translate loads of makework documents at your cost and have your prospective mate be vetted as if he were a threat to national security in order to be allowed to marry?

Would you perhaps think that it might be an unreasonable burden on your freedom as a woman? No? You think, then, that abortion laws are a radical restriction on your sexual and reproductive freedom, but making you and your partner jump through hoops left and right in order to get married - or even to FLIRT, for chrissakes - is just good sense...?

Given that you don't think that the government should be involved as a duenna in your love life, then what exactly is the ethical and moral argument for subjecting foreign women to sort of dog and pony show VAWA's IMB rider postulates...?

As VAWA currently stands, I don't think I can support it. Yes, it does some good things and maybe those outweight the bad. It's hard for me to say. All I know is that for the one bit of the sex/gender/immigration/violence question that I can reasonably claim some degree of expertise on, VAWA is not likely to do much good and may do quite a lot of bad.

I thus suggest that those of you who are concerned with women's issues, gender and violence, take a good hard look at what VAWA actually does in your areas of expertise before you support this bill. It does not deserve to be supported, reflexively, simply because it has a nice, appealing title.

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Hugo Schwyzer, male feminist, publicly self-destructs


 

The popular and prolific sex-and-gender blogger Hugo Schwyzer has apparently been banned from the feminist pale following his confession that he attempted to kill himself and an ex-girlfriend in 1998. You can read about the controversy here…. 

I have had something of a love/hate relationship with Hugo ever since we virtually met in the course of a debate regarding men’s rights activists on The Good Man Projectin early 2011.  Hugo is routinely accused by men’s rights activists of being a “mangina” in the sense that he almost reflexively takes an orthodox feminist position with regards to any issue. He has also been accused, more than once, of grandstanding: setting himself up as some sort of male “hero of the feminist movement” to which other men should look as a positive role model. My problems with Hugo were originally of a more academic and theoretical nature, as I outlined in my original article in TGMP.

Basically, I feel that Hugo Schwyzer is motivated by a secularized Christian view of social conflict, whereby any situation can be cleanly divided into a dichotic set, with one side being “the good guys” and the other the bad. Such a view of power and social conflict has been obsolete within the social sciences for several decades now, but Hugo apparently hasn’t upgraded his theory booklet since the 1980s. Because of this, he views gender, basically, as an absolute divide with “men” set unquestioningly as Evil Oppressors with “women”  being absolutely blameless and oppressed. The only possible role men can play in deconstructing the sex/gender system, in this view, is to deconstruct themselves, aiding “feminists” (a group Schwyzer never clearly defines) in their goals (which, again, are never defined beyond vague notions such as “destroying patriarchy”).

More troublesome to me is the fact that Hugo simply doesn’t seem able or willing to take an intersectional view of power and oppression, whereby multiple axes of identitary differentiation and their associated privileges interact to create concrete instances of (dis)empowerment.  While he nods his head towards race, class, sexual identity, nationality and other identity constructs, he doesn’t seem to grasp how these create a kyriarchic – rather than a patriarchic – structure. It seems to me that in Hugo’s world view, gender trumps all… and a very conservatively imagined notion of gender, at that.

Throughout 2010 and 2011, Hugo was a prolific blogger and commentator on TGMP and, in the course of his writing, he began to make a series of confessions. He originally started off by commenting that, as a professor, he had had sex with a student. As a university professor myself, this comment was troubling to me, but not excessively so. I think that professors shouldn’t ever mix their role as teacher with sexual/affective roles, but I’ve seen enough good people break this rule to realize that things in the real world are never quite that simple. In Hugo’s case, it didn’t seem that abuse of power was involved (the woman was significantly older than Hugo, for one thing) and the relationship had apparently occurred some time after Hugo had taught the woman in question as a student in class.

Men’s rights activists didn’t take long, however, in attempting to tar-and-feather Hugo, calling him a “professor who sexually abuses his students”. That seemed to me to be over the top and uncalled for and, on several occasions, I stood up for Hugo against his attackers, saying that one relationship with an older, adult, ex-student did not make Schwyzer into some sort of classroom Lothario.

As time went on, however, Hugo began to reveal even more of his past life. Apparently he slept with several students, some while he was teaching them, some who were much younger than he.

I felt a bit of a patsy for having defended Hugo and you can see my reaction to these revelations here.  Now here’s the strange bit: on August 14th, I posted the following commentary in reaction to one of Hugo’s confessional pieces:

The way Hugo is “unfolding” and revealing himself to The Good Men Project’s readers, like some sort weird tropical flower, I’m wondering if we won’t soon be hearing confessions, on his part, to date rape.

Lo and behold, 4 months later, Hugo admitted not to date rape, but to attempted murder  of a female partner.

I guess I must say that I’m not surprised.

Hugo Schwyzer’s  background is deeply religious, with a thin layer of Marxist dialecticism laid down on top. I don’t wonder that the man, who once claimed to be a Trotskyite, now believes that the Christian god is his personal savior. Hugo seems to have grappled, throughout his life, with a powerful impetus to self-destruction that also occasionally takes swipes at the people around him. Many men and women have similar problems with a drive towards thanatos and guilt and Hugo gets full marks, in my book, for being publically honest and forthcoming about his problems. That takes guts and commitment and nobody should look down on the man because he’s taken this stance, even though , as Ozmandius has pointed out, “Hugo has managed to achieve a feat no one thought he could achieve before: MRAs and radfems, masculists and feminists, standing side by side, united in their hatred for Hugo Schwyzer”. 

What bothers me about all this, however, is how many feminists and feminist-supportive men seemed to have voted Hugo Schwyzer, sight unseen, as feminist man of the year, before the revelations about his past started surfacing.  Also troublesome is how after the man has been pilloried as “insufficiently feminist” now that his past has been revealed.

I was always chary of Hugo’s repeated attempts to use his own, admittedly extreme, experiences as some sort of guide to normative male behavior. I am a university professor and I have never slept with students or even been attracted to the idea and Hugo’s views that all university professors feel the same way he does are, to me, ridiculous. Likewise, Hugo’s repeated experiences with substance abuse, abusive relationships,  serial marriages and divorce are all beyond most men’s experiences. Simply put, most men’s lives are nowhere near as dramatic as Hugo claims his has been.

It often seemed to me that Hugo was unquestioningly accepted as “the voice of the feminist male” by a significant portion of the feminist blogosphere precisely because of his checkered past. Here was a man who admitted to doing many of the things certain feminists feel are normative among men: suicidal tendencies, violence, sexual abuse, emotional dependence, drug and alcohol abuse… it was all there. Everything except a confession to actual violence against a woman. But, as I intimidated in my August comments on TGMP, realistically speaking, how could we expect a man who admitted to doing all these things to have never taken a crack at his partner?

And now people claim to be surprised and say that they have been “taken in”…?

To me, that indicates that there are a lot of people out there in the gender blogosphere who have a very unrealistic understanding of human nature and whose view of good and evil is even more simplistic and extreme than Hugo Schwyzer’s.

Look: if you want to believe that (wo)men are the root of all evil, go ahead. But when you start hearing someone talk about how they’ve routinely fucked up their life, abused themselves and acted totally irresponsibly towards others, then don’t presume that said person’s  loudly declaimed ideology somehow makes things all OK.

What’s sad is that anyone with a rooted, reality-based notion of human behavior could easily see what kind of person Hugo Schwyzer is and where he was going with his confessions months ago, and yet he was still presumed by many in the feminist blogosphere to be “one of the good guys” because he was, after all, a feminist.

Likewise, now that Hugo has been “outted” as  having victimized women (somehow all the other violence he was doing in his life was essentially acceptable as long as it didn’t directly and physically target women), a significant portion of the gender blogosphere seems to want to believe that nothing he says or ever has said could have any validity whatsoever. Hugo’s articles are now being taken down by sites and blogs such as Feministe and Scarleteen where they were once routinely praised.

The controversy around Hugo Schwyzer reveals an unsavory side of the debate regarding gender in the Anglophonic blogosphere. As Raphael Magarik points out “The details of [Hugo’s] fall are telling. ‘Severing ties’ (or, in the case of Feministe, denying links) is not about ideological critique, but social ostracism.” Many people apparently thought – and still think – that debates regarding gender should not be based on ideas, but rather upon the popularity of the debaters.

If Hugo Schwyzer is who he says he is – a man who has had a very rocky past and who has come to a measure of peace with himself and the world through feminist introspection – then he should be a very welcome member of the debates  regarding gender now ongoing in our society. If, on the other hand, Hugo Schwyzer is an opportunist asshole, a victimizer and manipulator who will always be such, then why, for heaven’s sake, did significant portions of the feminist blogosphere champion him as a “sane male voice”, even as he admitted to his past history of abuse ?

Either we accept that men can change or we don’t. Holding someone up as a paragon of masculinity when his past problems with abuse, violence and manipulation are only too obvious, then ostracizing him because of those problems, is hypocritical and ridiculous. Certain people were happy to give Hugo a voice when he admitted to being a self-destructive, addictive, irresponsible asshole because all these traits were supposedly in his past: feminism had allowed him to overcome them.  Now when we find out, quite predictably, that “past Hugo” was also violent to women, we’re supposed to pretend that the man has never said a single damned useful thing about gender?

In the words of the immortal Bob Gideon, “Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight.”

Thursday, January 19, 2012

Explaining the "Luiza está no Canadá" meme to your gringo friends...

Been hearing alot about Luiza (who's in Canada), from your Brazilian netacquaintences lately? My pal Regina at Deep Brazil can explain the meme to you:
"Instant Youtube success: Gerardo Rabello, a social columnist from João Pessoa, capital of the state of Paraíba, announces a new construction project and says it is so great that all the family will attend the launching ceremony, apart from his daughter “Luiza, who is in Canada”. The phrase, mysteriously, became viral. In only two days, dozens of “comments” and mockumentaries about it were published on Youtube."

The reason this meme went viral has little to do with the fact that Gerardo Rabello is bragging in an off-handed fashion about his daughter's international travels. It has to do with Brazilian cordiality and family values and also with Brazilian sarcasm when cordiality is taken too far.

Rabello is basically telling us that "Look, I'm putting my family's good name behind this project". This is a traditionalist, kitchy and smarmy sort of thing to do. Maybe it goes over well with the folks from Paraíba, but to the large number of Brazilians living in São Paulo and Rio (the dominant force on the lusophone internet), it sounds like a corny homily to 19th century values. The ad is thus irksome to begin with.

But then Rabello upped the already high smarm factor by explaining to us all why one of his daughters won't be attending this mighty social event of the Paraiban summer. As if we knew his children by name. As if we would wonder why we wouldn't see Luiza at the event. As if we all lived in the same tiny little backlands village or even knew who the hell Gerardo Rabello and his spawn were.

As if, in short, we gave a tremendous fuck.

Urbane, networked Brazil thus responded in false cordial style, dripping with fake bonhomie and neighborly concern.

Suddenly, we all needed to know where Luiza was. What she was doing? Was she eating well? Did she have a boyfriend yet? Was he Canadian...? We demanded that the government investigate why Luiza was still in Canada and worried whether the heartless gringos would deport her. (Certainly not Luiza! Such a nice moça de família!)

And, of course, we're all breathing a hearty sigh of relieved satisfaction now that she's come home to the pátria amada.

People who didn't get this meme or are taken it at face value as a form of instant celebrity manufacture don't understand the depths of Brazilian sarcasm when it combines with false cordiality. There's a reason why "cair na boca do povo" is understood to be a bad thing in Brazil.
The meme is also a good example of why memes become old quickly and how they warp (rather than evolve) into news.

The first folks reporting on Luiza's whereabouts were net nerds who had seen the original comme
rcial first-hand on You-Tube and found it corny beyond belief. They were making arch comments to their friends, who had also seen it. This is precisely the same sort of crowd who loves to wax enthusiastic about the Trololo Guy*. (You know, folks like this...)

Thus was the original iteration of the meme born and it was funny, if not hilarious.

Then legions of script-kiddies and Brazilian adolescents who fancy themselves to be Anonymous got ahold of the meme and started spamming it into everything, making old meme very old, very quickly.

Following this, the Brazilian NORPS** saw the script-kiddies' net graffiti, wondered what was up and had to have everything explained to them. This effectively killed any remaining humor that the meme once had.

Finally, the Old Media got ahold of the Luiza story. The Old Media speaks to people who hardly use the internet at all and whose understanding of memes is on the level of a flatworm's understanding of brain surgery. The only framework the Old Media has for dealing with this sort of thing is to treat Luiza as some sort of minor instant celebrity. And that, friends, is precisely how Globo is dealing with this little bit of internet arcana right at this very moment.
 

*If you don't know who the Trololo Guy is, remember: there is no such thing as brain bleach.

**NORP = Normal, Ordinary, Responsible Person. The vast majority of internet users who go on-lin
e simply to check e-mail and send each other pictures of their cats - see expanded definition here.